Employment solicitors in Warrington warn of expensive holiday pay claims after ECJ ruling

January 10, 2018

Employers who have wrongly classed their workers as self-employed contractors could now face substantial claims for unpaid holiday, following a recent ruling by the European Court of Justice (ECJ) in the case of King v The Sash Window Workshop Ltd. 

Latham Parry, a solicitor specialising in Employment Law in Warrington, says that the ECJ ruling in King has significant ramifications in relation to the right to holiday pay in the UK.

Mr Parry, who heads the Employment Law Team at Watsons Solicitors, Warrington, said: “Companies often regard people who work for them as self-employed, independent contractors, but the reality isn’t always so. The employment tribunals and courts have recently dealt with a number of high profile cases including UberAddison Lee and CitySprint, where so-called self-employed contractors have been able to establish ‘worker’ status, meaning that they acquire certain legal rights, including the right to paid annual leave.

“The EJC decision in King means that an employer who prevents a worker from taking paid holiday because the employer refuses to grant paid holiday, for example, because the employer wrongly classes the individual as self-employed, is preventing the worker from exercising EU rights.

“The decision goes further and means if the employer refuses to grant paid holiday, the worker can now carry over his entitlement to the following holiday year and therefore accumulate these rights from previous years.

“Claims for holiday pay could potentially be made to as far back as 1996, when the original Working Time Directive came into force.”

Established as an Employment Law solicitor in Warrington, Mr Parry added: “The ruling applies to four weeks’ European annual holiday, so each worker could claim up to 4 weeks’ holiday pay for the last 20 years, or 80 weeks’ pay. This could be financially disastrous for companies which have wrongly classed large numbers of their workers as self-employed.”

In King, Mr King had been believed to be self-employed, so his ’employer’ had not granted paid holiday.

An employment tribunal then held that he was a worker, entitled to 5.6 weeks’ paid annual leave under the Working Time Regulations 1998, and also that he was entitled to compensation for holiday not taken in previous years.

The employer argued that the Working Time Regulations 1998 provide that, if paid holiday is not taken in a leave year, it is lost, and successfully appealed to the Employment Appeal Tribunal on this point.

Mr King appealed to the Court of Appeal, which then made a reference to the ECJ.

The ECJ said that any worker prevented from taking paid holiday because the employer refuses to grant it, is being denied his EU rights. The ECJ also held that an employer who fails to grant paid holiday to workers should not be entitled to the benefits of the normal limits on how much can be carried over.

Click for more information about employment law.

Contact Us

If you are interested or require any information on any of our services then please get in touch for an appointment on:

 01925 571 212
Mon-Fri: 9am - 5pm

Latest News

Compromise is the perfect solution to flexible working requests

A Cheshire-based employment law specialist believes compromise is the ideal solution to flexible working requests. The goalposts shifted considerably during the coronavirus pandemic with almost half of adults working from home. According to data from the Opinions and Lifestyle Survey (OPN), more than eight in 10 workers who had to do their job from home […]

Ageing population highlights importance of writing a will

A Cheshire-based wills and probate solicitor thinks that there is no time like the present for getting your affairs in order and writing a will with the age of the population on the rise. Recently released figures from the Office for National Statistics (ONS) revealed that the number of people in England and Wales aged […]

Family solicitor Lauren celebrates anniversary with step towards key accreditation

Lauren Soutar marked her one-year anniversary at Watsons Solicitors by taking a significant step closer to acquiring the Law Society’s Children Law Accreditation. Tuesday 18 October was exactly one-year since Lauren joined the Warrington-based firm as a family lawyer. By the time that date came around, Lauren had undertaken the Children Law scheme’s mandatory three-day […]

Trainee solicitor Hannah shortlisted for top Warrington Business Awards honour

Hannah Dale and Watsons Solicitors are celebrating after the trainee was shortlisted for the Apprentice of the Year honour at the prestigious Warrington Business Awards. Hannah is on the three-strong shortlist for the award which is open to any individual who has undergone a full-time training position during the period from January 2020 to September […]

Watsons Solicitors
Lexel Accreditation
Children Law Accredited
Conveyancing Quality

Watsons Solicitors is a trading name of Watsons Solicitors Warrington LLP a Limited Liability Partnership registered in England and Wales registered number OC386012 whose registered office is 13 Bold Street, Warrington, WA1 1DJ.

Watsons Solicitors Warrington LLP is authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority number 598547.

Website managed by Outwrite PR, an online reputation management agency
envelope-oclock-ophonefax linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram